When it was time for Sara Hammel’s son, David, to oust his pacifiers, she let the Easter Bunny handle it.
Hammel, of McCandless, and her husband, Michael, had David — who was almost 3 at the time, and is now 8 — gather up all of his “dewies” and place them in empty plastic Easter eggs. He placed the eggs, along with some carrots, out on the night before Easter. The next morning, David was delighted to find a giant Easter egg filled with Matchbox toys.
“He totally went along with it. … It was almost amazing,” says Sara Hammel, 30. “He never asked about it — not ever, not once.”
In early childhood, giving up pacifiers — often called “binkies” — is a major step in growing up, but it’s not always easy for the child or parent. The baby’s pacifier serves as an outlet for sucking instincts, and a source of comfort and soothing, experts say. Yet, when the time comes to outgrow it, if the parents do it right, most children do surprisingly well. Making the change can be quite simple, and done either cold-turkey style or through a gradual weaning process.
“It’s something many parents put off doing; they think the child is going to have a terrible reaction,” says Dr. Lawrence Shapiro. He is a child psychologist in Norwalk, Conn., and author of several parenting books, including “It’s Time to Give Up Your Pacifier.”
“Children are resilient, for the most part,” Shapiro says. “Children may be upset for a day or two, but that’s it. … Parents can take (the pacifier) away, and tell the child, ‘You’re a big boy or big girl, and big boys and big girls don’t suck pacifiers.’ And that should be the end of it.”
Dr. Christopher Luccy, a pediatric dentist in Greensburg, Westmoreland County, recommends that parents eliminate a baby’s pacifiers ideally between the ages of 11 and 13 months — although it’s very common for children to use a pacifier much longer than that.
“Once you get past 11 to 13 months, a pacifier … is not a … necessity, but rather a pathological habit,” Luccy says.
Prolonged pacifier use can cause damage to a child’s facial and jaw growth pattern, and push the teeth out for an awkward bite, resulting in “buck teeth,” he says. Toddlers who use a pacifier for a few years can easily break their teeth when they fall, because of the teeth’s positions.
Shapiro — whose simple picture book about pacifiers is meant to be read by parents and children together — says that children should stop using pacifiers around 1 year old, and by 18 months at the latest. Once children are a year old, they lose the sucking instinct catered to by a pacifier.
“After that, (the pacifier) doesn’t serve any purpose whatsoever, but it’s just a habit,” Shapiro says.
If a child uses a pacifier for too long, he or she can have impaired language development, and be subject to teasing by peers, Shapiro says.
Many parents have found creative and humorous ways to end their children’s pacifier days.
After her son, Ryan’s, 2-year examination with his pediatrician, Jennifer Rametta of Allegheny Township decided to get rid of the pacifiers once and for all. She and her husband, Mike, tied them to a bunch of helium balloons and released them into the sky, while Ryan watched, thinking he was doing a noble deed.
“We said there were babies up on the moon who need the pacifiers more than he did, because he’s a big boy now,” says Jennifer Rametta, 37.
The tactic worked well: Ryan, now 6, only asked about the pacifier when he took his nap that day, then dropped it. Just when his parents were celebrating, though, they saw some of the balloons tangled up around the electric wires outside the house — and later, they found a binky in their flower beds.
Heather and Patrick Brennan of Jeannette, Westmoreland County, also tricked their daughter, Rachel, who is now 6. When they saw a newspaper picture of Patrick Brennan, a law enforcement officer, escorting a prisoner, the couple told Rachel that the man stole her binky from her father and buried it in the woods. They put the clipping on the refrigerator, to remind her.
With their other daughter — Riley, 2 — the couple claimed that the Jeannette Jayhawks, a high-school football team, stole her binkies. Specifically, they said that Terrelle Pryor — the football standout who will play for Ohio State — took the binkies.
“God forbid if she should ever meet him,” says Heather Brennan, 28, laughing. “She’d say, ‘You took my binky!’ ”
Heather Upholster, 36, of Unity, Westmoreland County, says her oldest child — Brenna, who will be 7 on July 5 — was still very attached to her binkies at age 3. When her doctor told her to get rid of the pacifier, Upholster blamed it on a herd of cows in a field they often passed while driving.
“I just kind of played dumb, and said, ‘I don’t know where it went; maybe those cows took it,” she says. Brenna would yell, “No fair! You guys took my binkie!”
“After a few weeks … she forgot all about the binkie and didn’t ask about it,” Upholster says.
For Donna Orris of Port Vue, the birth of her son, Mark, jolted her older daughter — Michele, who was 3 1/2 at the time — out of her dependence on her pacifier.
“All of a sudden, she instantly became the big sister,” says Orris, 66. She used to put several pacifiers in her daughter’s crib, so the tot wouldn’t have to reach too far for one.
“And that was that,” she says.
NO MORE BINKY
If it’s time to retire the old binky, consider this advice from professionals:
• It’s good to begin taking pacifiers away, whether by weaning or cold-turkey methods, when your child is about a year old, and as young as 11 months.
• By the time kids reach 18 months, they definitely are ready to give up the pacifiers entirely.
• Whether to go cold turkey or gradually depends on the individual child and age. Older children, who may have become more dependent on their pacifiers, might do better with a weaning process.
• If you suddenly take the pacifier away, be prepared for a few days of protesting and crying from your child, but don’t give in. Many kids get over it right away.
• If you take the pacifier away gradually, start by telling your kids that it is time to stop using it, except at home, and that soon they won’t need it. A week later, tell them they can only use it at bedtime. On the third week, tell them they are big boys or girls and don’t need it at all.
• When you’re done, throw all pacifiers away.
• Give your child a special stuffed toy to take to bed, to replace the comfort of the pacifier.
• Be consistent. Once you have a good plan, stick to it, and never give the pacifier back.
• Avoid quitting the pacifier during a time of change, like a move, a new school year, or the birth of a new baby.
• Do not give your kid a hard time, even if he or she gives you one.
• Don’t make your child feel bad about wanting the pacifier back; be empathetic.
• Portray a positive attitude; this is a major milestone in your child’s life, like potty-training.
• Emphasize the compliment that your child is now a big boy or big girl, to boost confidence.
TAKE-AWAY METHODS
When you take the pacifier away, these methods may help:
• Break the pacifier by cutting off the nipple, then tell your child that it’s broken and needs to be thrown away.
• Ask your dentist to tell your child that the pacifier is bad for the teeth.
• Give stickers to your kids when they don’t use the pacifier.
• Dip the pacifier in soapy water so that it will taste bad.
• Make up creative stories, like telling your child that the Binky Fairy will come while he or she is sleeping, and leave a stuffed toy and maybe a note.
Source: Pittsburgh Tribune-Review, PA
http://www.pittsburghlive.com/x/pittsburghtrib/living/family/s_570626.html